Theresa May’s government loses contempt vote over Brexit legal advice

Vastavam web: British Prime Minister Theresa May’s government was found in contempt of parliament on Tuesday for refusing to release its full legal advice on Brexit, underlining the depth of opposition among lawmakers to her deal on leaving the European Union. The row threatened to overshadow the start of five days of debate in parliament on May’s Brexit deal ahead of a crucial vote on Dec. 11, when lawmakers will be asked to approve it.

They put forward a motion, which was backed by 311-293 in a vote on Tuesday, that found ministers in contempt of parliament and ordered the immediate publication of the advice. “Today’s finding of contempt is a badge of shame for this government. It is of huge constitutional and political significance,” Keir Starmer, the opposition Labour Party’s Brexit spokesman, said after the vote. “Never before has the House of Commons found ministers in contempt of parliament.”

Such punishment is usually reserved for backbench lawmakers guilty of individual wrongdoing. In reality, Tuesday’s vote was about putting pressure on a weakened government. Catherine Haddon, senior fellow at the Institute for Government, said the opposition wanted to use “every opportunity they have to show the instability of the government”. So many lawmakers – from May’s own Conservatives as well as from the opposition parties – have spoken out against the deal that the odds look stacked against her winning the Dec. 11 vote.

Haddon said the contempt motion was a “show of force” which could foreshadow both the final vote on the deal and the various amendments lawmakers are trying to attach to it. Cox gave parliament an outline of his legal advice to the government on Monday. She said the government, which had sought to slow down the process by referring the issue to parliament’s Committee of Privileges, had fulfilled the spirit of the order to publish.